Your Reading List

  • Step up: Agriculture can’t ignore PR wars

    February 5, 2009 News
  • Report urges more vets for rural Manitoba

    January 29, 2009 News
  • Seaway traffic down five per cent in 2008

    January 15, 2009 News
  • Mexico joins Canada in WTO complaint against U. S.

    January 8, 2009 News
  • High feed intake essential in lactation

    January 1, 2009 Dairy cattle
  • News
  • Crops
  • Livestock
  • Markets
  • Weather
  • Farmit
  • Op/Ed
  • Video
  • Digital Editions
  • Classifieds
  • Subscriptions
  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Glacier FarmMedia
  • Ag in Motion
  • Western Producer
  • Manitoba Cooperator
  • Alberta Farmer Express
  • Canadian Outdoor Farm Show
  • GrowPro
  • Farmzilla
  • Weatherfarm
  • Country-Guide
  • MORE
    • Alberta Farmer Express
    • Canadian Outdoor Farm Show
    • GrowPro
    • Farmzilla
    • Weatherfarm
    • Country-Guide
    • Farm Forum Event
    • Discovery Farm
    • Canadian Cattlemen
    • Agricole Idéal
    • Farm Auction Guide
    • Le Bulletin des agriculteurs
    • Food in Canada
    • Farmtario
    • MarketsFarm
    • AgDealer
    • Grainews
    • Advancing Women in Agriculture Conference
Glacier FarmMedia COVID-19 & the Farm
Manitoba Co-operator
Manitoba Co-operator
MENUMENU
  • News
      • Manitoba Pulse and Soybean Growers saw funding rebound in 2020 March 2, 2021
      • Chinese researchers find natural mutation in African swine fever virus March 2, 2021
      • U.S. forecasts record combined U.S. soy, corn acreage for 2021 March 1, 2021
      • The four horsemen of the crop-pocalypse March 1, 2021
      View all News
  • Crops
      • The four horsemen of the crop-pocalypse March 1, 2021
      • Chorney given Canola Award of Excellence February 19, 2021
      • Canola foes the same — but different February 17, 2021
      • Calling all farmers: Seed regs review kicks off February 11, 2021
      View all Crops
  • Livestock
          • What to do for a yearling? March 2, 2021
          • Time for a shift on livestock price insurance? February 26, 2021
          • Contaminated feed a risk that can’t be ignored, says expert February 24, 2021
          View all Livestock
        • Livestock Sales
  • Markets
          • U.S. forecasts record combined U.S. soy, corn acreage for 2021 March 1, 2021
          • Auction activity recovers as colder spell retreats February 26, 2021
          • ICE canola futures acting independently February 25, 2021
          View all Markets
        • Markets at a glance
  • Weather
      • Explaining the cold snap, ordering a weather station March 2, 2021
      • Forecast: Milder, with a slight chance of snow February 25, 2021
      • Switching up my personal weather station February 24, 2021
      • Forecast: Cold snap slowly coming to an end February 18, 2021
      View all Weather
  • Farmit
      • Manitoba home of moringa ‘miracle tree’ innovation February 24, 2021
      • Agriculture after the pandemic February 23, 2021
      • Family puts heart and homegrown produce into pet food business February 17, 2021
      • Young farmers call for better rural childcare February 11, 2021
      View all Farmit
  • Op/Ed
      • Opinion: Dairy producers should be more transparent March 2, 2021
      • Editorial: The carbon credit reality February 25, 2021
      • Comment: The end of cities? February 23, 2021
      • Comment: Food safety nationalism February 17, 2021
      View all Op/Ed
  • Digital Editions
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Classified
  • Place Ad
Manitoba Co-operator
Free Newsletter Signup

Your Reading List

  • Step up: Agriculture can’t ignore PR wars

    February 5, 2009 News
  • Report urges more vets for rural Manitoba

    January 29, 2009 News
  • Seaway traffic down five per cent in 2008

    January 15, 2009 News
  • Mexico joins Canada in WTO complaint against U. S.

    January 8, 2009 News
  • High feed intake essential in lactation

    January 1, 2009 Dairy cattle
Manitoba Co-operator
MENUMENU
  • News
      • Manitoba Pulse and Soybean Growers saw funding rebound in 2020 March 2, 2021
      • Chinese researchers find natural mutation in African swine fever virus March 2, 2021
      • U.S. forecasts record combined U.S. soy, corn acreage for 2021 March 1, 2021
      • The four horsemen of the crop-pocalypse March 1, 2021
      View all News
  • Crops
      • The four horsemen of the crop-pocalypse March 1, 2021
      • Chorney given Canola Award of Excellence February 19, 2021
      • Canola foes the same — but different February 17, 2021
      • Calling all farmers: Seed regs review kicks off February 11, 2021
      View all Crops
  • Livestock
          • What to do for a yearling? March 2, 2021
          • Time for a shift on livestock price insurance? February 26, 2021
          • Contaminated feed a risk that can’t be ignored, says expert February 24, 2021
          View all Livestock
        • Livestock Sales
  • Markets
          • U.S. forecasts record combined U.S. soy, corn acreage for 2021 March 1, 2021
          • Auction activity recovers as colder spell retreats February 26, 2021
          • ICE canola futures acting independently February 25, 2021
          View all Markets
        • Markets at a glance
  • Weather
      • Explaining the cold snap, ordering a weather station March 2, 2021
      • Forecast: Milder, with a slight chance of snow February 25, 2021
      • Switching up my personal weather station February 24, 2021
      • Forecast: Cold snap slowly coming to an end February 18, 2021
      View all Weather
  • Farmit
      • Manitoba home of moringa ‘miracle tree’ innovation February 24, 2021
      • Agriculture after the pandemic February 23, 2021
      • Family puts heart and homegrown produce into pet food business February 17, 2021
      • Young farmers call for better rural childcare February 11, 2021
      View all Farmit
  • Op/Ed
      • Opinion: Dairy producers should be more transparent March 2, 2021
      • Editorial: The carbon credit reality February 25, 2021
      • Comment: The end of cities? February 23, 2021
      • Comment: Food safety nationalism February 17, 2021
      View all Op/Ed
  • Digital Editions
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Classified
  • Place Ad

Facebook Twitter Instagram

manitoba co-operator | response to covid-19

Special coverage | COVID-19 & the Farm

HOT TOPICS | PULSES - REGISTER NOW TO SAVE YOUR SEAT

manitoba co-operator | response to covid-19

Special coverage | COVID-19 & the Farm

HOT TOPICS | PULSES - REGISTER NOW TO SAVE YOUR SEAT

Step up: Agriculture can’t ignore PR wars

Gord Gilmour
By Gord Gilmour
Editor
Reading Time: 4 minutes
Published: February 5, 2009
News

“We’re just not great communicators, compared to our adversaries.”

– Kevin Stewart, agvisiontv.com

It might be easy to roll one’s eyes at the latest campaigns from People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) – such as their attempt to rebrand fish “sea-kittens” in an attempt to make people reconsider eating them.

Truth is, PETA and other interest groups like them are highly sophisticated and well-funded groups that understand the importance of winning the public relations battle. They also understand that there’s no such thing as bad publicity.

ADVERTISEMENT

All this points to an inescapable conclusion, says Kevin Stewart of AgvisionTV.com.Agriculture needs to get its act together with its own unified message or run the risk of losing control of the industry.

Speaking here at Manitoba Potato Production Days, Stewart told farmers everything from the Walkerton water tragedy to recent food scares is causing consumers to slowly lose faith in the food system – and agriculture is typically slow to respond, offering a fragmented message at best.

“To the media I think it’s beginning to resemble a choir without a conductor,” Stewart said. “It’s just noise.”

Facts didn’t matter

Stewart pointed to the Walkerton water story as a perfect example of how a farmer can be scapegoated. Within a couple of days of the story breaking, activists had organized a media event in front of a pig barn decrying the impact of large-scale animal agriculture operation on water quality and safety – despite the fact that pork operations had no connection to the event.

ADVERTISEMENT

In the end the initial source of the tragedy was traced back to a small-scale beef feedlot that investigators later said was well run and obeying all the rules. The real problem, they said, was a poorly maintained well, located in a low-lying area where it never should have been sited, and a water treatment system that was criminally managed.

But the facts didn’t matter by the time that came out, because the perception of the public had already been formed, Stewart said.

“In a crisis situation, if you hear something three times and no one refutes it, it’s deemed as true,” Stewart says. “Every time a negative event happens, we just cringe and say nothing.”

“We’re just not great communicators, compared to our adversaries.”

That’s especially troubling in light of the recent spate of bad news surrounding food. From listeriosis to BSE and everything in between, it’s all causing people to question the safety of food.

Stewart showed a number of reader comments from food safety stories on the CBC’s web-sites and they were universally negative. Most were aimed at the food system overall, but there’s a risk farmers will get tarred with the same brush.

“Every time we say nothing, we make a withdrawal from that bank account (of consumer goodwill) and people become a bit more cynical,” Stewart said.

ADVERTISEMENT

Strategies

So what’s the answer? Studying your enemies’ tactics and adopting them as your own, Stewart says. For example, there’s the near-constant media attention that groups like PETA command. These groups have clear-cut communications strategies.

“Their first rule is ‘Keep the pressure on,’” Stewart says. “They understand that the two strongest forces in nature are time and pressure.”

It’s the same when it comes to fighting a PR war. The constant media exposure these groups garner slowly, over time, begins shifting public opinion, no matter how outrageous their tactics might seem. Minus the outrageous tactics, Stewart says, it’s a strategy agriculture should also follow.

“We can’t simply step to the microphone when something troubling happens,” he says. “We need to start a dialogue on an ongoing basis.”

Farmers bring a lot of good tools to the table that will help them win this battle – not least of which is the fact that again and again Canadians consistently identify farmers as among the most trusted individuals in the country, along with those in occupations such as firefighting.

“Farmers – not agriculture – have a very strong brand,” Stewart said.

In Ontario, where he runs his TV production company, Stewart is involved in a project aimed at putting the power of the brand to work on behalf of agriculture. It’s a pilot project between the Ontario government and almost all the provincial farm organizations.

Their goal is to produce TV advertisements and web content, not just to correct misconceptions about farming, but to generally promote the role of farmers in the food system and highlight the safety of Canadian food.

Farmers need to step forward and tell their stories, he said, or someone else will tell them. Farmers also have to be prepared to accept that there will be a cost to do so. They don’t have to like that fact, he said, but they have to accept it.

“In case of disaster”

“It’s like an insurance policy: there might be a cost, but there’s also a value,” Stewart says. “It’s not a luxury – it’s in case of disaster.”

Stewart showed three TV commercials that will begin airing shortly as part of the campaign. All put a face on the concept of a farmer and explained the benefits of agriculture to society at large.

One key to connecting with consumers will be understanding that farmers and non-farmers generally speak two different languages. For example, when issues come up, consumers generally talk about values issues: Were animals treated humanely? Is a product safe and wholesome for them and their family? But farmers, industry groups and companies have tended to fall back into their own science-based rationale.

“That sounds uncaring, when consumers are talking about values issues,” Stewart said. “You need to talk in the language of the society.”

[email protected]

About the author

Gord Gilmour

Editor

Gord Gilmour
Email icon  

Gord Gilmour is Editor of the Manitoba Co-operator.

Gord Gilmour's recent articles

  • Editor’s Take: Child care a necessity February 11, 2021
  • Editor’s Take: The digital divide February 4, 2021
  • The great disruptor January 26, 2021

More Articles

Related Coverage

News, food


Free virtual cooking class with Trevor Lui

News, food


Thai researcher wonders if chicken feathers on the menu might fly

News, food


Studies in soil science, ag practices earn national scholarships

News, food


Culinary in the age of COVID

News, food


Video series busts hunger myths

News, food


Quest to brand Canada’s food is drawing industry-wide interest

Comments

explore

Stories from our other publications

  • Alberta Farmer Express

    Olymel closure due to COVID creates costly backlog for hog producers

    hogs

    Olymel closure due to COVID creates costly backlog for hog producers

  • Farmtario

    Free satellite images available from OneSoil

    machinery

    Free satellite images available from OneSoil

  • The Western Producer

    Beef sector saw winners and losers during COVID

    farm living

    Beef sector saw winners and losers during COVID

  • Farmtario

    Capture and removal of phosphorus pitched

    news

    Capture and removal of phosphorus pitched

GFM Network News

  • Pulse packers’ security covers cash owed to farmers

    11 hours ago
  • Farm cash receipts up in 2020

    12 hours ago
  • U.S. grains: Soy, corn up on unfavourable South American weather

    13 hours ago
More News →

Podcasts

  • between-the-rows
  • Food connectivity, travel perplexity, canola’s desirability

    February 25, 2021
  • Listen Now →

Special Podcast

Between The Rows

  • Listen » Reflections on pandemic life. How are we doing?

AgCanadaTV

AGCanadaTV: In Case You Missed It – Your National Ag News Recap for the week ending February 26, 2021.

Sponsored By:
More Videos →

Daily Newsletter

Subscribe to the Manitoba Co-operator daily newsletter

You'll receive current daily news every morning free, as well as market updates and special features.

* PERMISSION TO CONTACT YOU BY EMAIL By providing your e-mail address, you confirm that you are providing consent to Glacier Farm Media LP, on its own behalf and on behalf of its affiliates, and carrying on business through its divisions, to receive emails containing news, updates and promotions, including third party promotions, as well as product and/or service information, including that of third parties, that may be of interest to you, and that you understand you may unsubscribe at any time. Please see contact us for more information.


flag
Signup to our Newsletter
  • News & Opinion
  • Crops
  • Livestock
  • Markets
  • Farmit
  • Video
  • Digital Editions
  • Classifieds
  • Subscriptions
  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise

Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy | © 2021, Glacier FarmMedia Limited Partnership

Banner image Close

With roots going back to 1925, each weekly issue of the Manitoba Co-operator contains production, marketing and policy news selected for relevance to crops and livestock producers in Manitoba.

Subscribe Today!

Free Newsletter Signup