U.S. pork processors face higher costs, slower speeds after court ruling

They’re asking the USDA to push back against the court ruling the agency failed to evaluate the effect of new rules on worker health

Reuters – An industry group representing North America’s biggest meat packers has pushed the U.S. Department of Agriculture to appeal a Federal Court decision that cancelled an agency rule that allows pork plants to slaughter pigs more quickly.

The decision issued on March 31 in U.S. District Court in Minnesota could raise costs for meat packers like Seaboard Foods and Clemens Food Group and slow meat production after COVID-19 outbreaks in slaughterhouses limited output last year.

A lawsuit brought against the USDA by the United Food and Commercial Workers Union had challenged the 2019 rule, arguing that faster slaughter speeds undermined worker safety.

A federal judge said there was no evidence the Trump-era rule had evaluated worker safety. USDA says it is evaluating the decision.

The North American Meat Institute, which represents meat companies, said it was disappointed in the verdict. The institute has argued that line-speed increases have not correlated with increased injury rates.

“We would like to see the agency appeal and ask for a stay,” the institute said.

Seaboard Foods, the second-biggest U.S. pig producer after Smithfield Foods, sped up its Guymon, Oklahoma, pork plant last year, becoming the first company to operate under the new rule. Workers told Reuters the faster line speeds increased injuries at the plant.

Seaboard did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

The rule change allowed pork plants to slaughter as fast as they want, as long as they prevent fecal contamination and minimize bacteria. The U.S. court stayed its decision to vacate the rule for 90 days, giving companies and the Biden administration time to adapt.

The elimination of line speeds was part of the New Swine Inspection System, which also lets pork plants use some company inspectors instead of USDA ones.

About the author


Tom Polansek reports on agriculture and ag commodities for Reuters from Chicago.



Stories from our other publications