Opinion: Farmers, workers deserve better than Switch

The company tasked with managing coronavirus tests for travellers entering Canada continues to cause headaches for farmers and the international workers they employ.

Switch Health is managing the tests being given to travellers pre- and post-arrival.

Over one year into the pandemic, it is reasonable to expect processes like this to be effectively managed. That has not been the case.

International farm workers and others entering Canada have complained about wait times accessing online Switch nurses, lost tests, delays and inaccurate results.

Ken Forth, president of Ontario’s Foreign Agricultural Resources Management Service (FARMS), told Glacier FarmMedia’s Diana Martin the stress among producers is “huge.”

“We’ve got our life on the line here, our financial life on the line of our families, and we’re relying on a lab test that cannot be done consistently,” said Forth.

Switch was offered nearly $100 million for its services. Better results are expected.

Social media is littered with complaints about the company.

Farmers deserve better.

More importantly, the thousands of people who choose to leave their homes and come to Canada for work deserve better.

Forcing workers to isolate for longer than necessary because of delays, or preventing them from working due to inaccurate test results, is not a good way to ensure goodwill among migrant workers.

There are reports of four migrant farm workers dying while in quarantine since mid-March. More died at other points throughout the pandemic. Mexico temporarily stopped workers from coming to Canada after work by migrant worker advocates.

Conditions for temporary foreign workers are precarious enough to bring legitimate calls for massive reforms.

The COVID-19 pandemic loudened those calls, particularly after farm worker deaths.

Advocates and academics have previously called on the government to give foreign workers access to Employment Insurance, improve on-farm enforcement of the rules and allow workers a better path to citizenship.

If Canada’s food supply chain is relying on these workers, then offering them these basics is a no-brainer.

The Migrant Rights Network continues to attract mainstream media attention for its advocacy on this file, most recently with the release of its report Exclusion, Disappointment, Chaos and Exploitation.

It takes direct aim at the federal government’s planned pathway to a permanent residency program for temporary workers.

That program is granting permanent status to temporary workers who possess certain skill sets and a portion of the 90,000 available slots will go to those involved in the production of food.

Critics say the program excludes more than one million migrant workers in Canada, including all of those living in Quebec. It has been critiqued for being too costly for applicants, and having stringent requirements to prove education or language competencies.

That echoes concerns raised by some farm groups, who contend previous pathway to permanent residency programs have come with too many stipulations, and expenses, attached.

This far into the pandemic, Canadians and temporary foreign workers deserve better.

A new report from Ontario’s deputy chief coroner offers 35 recommendations to improve safety for migrant workers in the province, including using isolation centres and random COVID tests.

At the very least, all governments in Canada should pay attention to reports like this.

Canadians, and migrant workers, deserve it.

About the author


D.C. Fraser

D.C. Fraser is Glacier FarmMedia’s Ottawa-based reporter. Growing up mostly in Alberta, Fraser also lived in Saskatchewan for ten years where he covered politics, including a stint teaching at the University of Regina’s School of Journalism. He is an avid fan of the outdoors and a pretty good beer league hockey player. His passion for agriculture and agri-food policy comes naturally: Six consecutive generations of his family have worked in the industry.



Stories from our other publications