Your Reading List

  • Canola Pool, Maybe. Wheat? Probably Not

    August 11, 2011 Cereals
  • Canola Tops For Farm Cash Receipts In 2010

    August 4, 2011 Cereals
  • Strong Dollar Tempers Canola Export Demand

    July 28, 2011 Cereals
  • Fruit Crops Look Good — Except Those Under Water

    July 21, 2011 Crops
  • UN Expert Urges Huge Investment In Small Farmers

    July 14, 2011 Crops
  • News
  • Crops
  • Livestock
  • Markets
  • Weather
  • Farmit
  • Op/Ed
  • Video
  • Digital Editions
  • Classifieds
  • Subscriptions
  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Glacier FarmMedia
  • Ag in Motion
  • Western Producer
  • Manitoba Cooperator
  • Alberta Farmer Express
  • Weatherfarm
  • Country-Guide
  • Food in Canada
  • AgDealer
  • MarketsFarm
  • MORE
    • Alberta Farmer Express
    • Weatherfarm
    • Country-Guide
    • Food in Canada
    • AgDealer
    • MarketsFarm
    • Advancing Women in Agriculture Conference
    • Farmtario
    • Grainews
    • Canadian Cattlemen
    • Le Bulletin des agriculteurs
    • Discovery Farm
    • GrowPro
    • Farm Auction Guide
    • Canadian Outdoor Farm Show
    • Agricole Idéal
    • Farmzilla
    • Farm Forum Event
Glacier FarmMedia COVID-19 & the Farm
Manitoba Co-operator
Manitoba Co-operator
MENUMENU
  • News
      • Livestock sector benefiting from mild winter weather January 15, 2021
      • Innovations Showcase heads up reined-in Ag Days January 14, 2021
      • Swath of MARD, MASC offices slated for closure January 14, 2021
      • Biologicals in agriculture: what’s old is new (and improved) January 13, 2021
      View all News
  • Crops
      • Biologicals in agriculture: what’s old is new (and improved) January 13, 2021
      • Canola ending stocks forecast lowered January 7, 2021
      • Targeting your crop enemies January 5, 2021
      • Overwintered canola can still have value, but process it quickly December 30, 2020
      View all Crops
  • Livestock
          • Livestock sector benefiting from mild winter weather January 15, 2021
          • Providing “a good death” for your horse when the time comes January 13, 2021
          • Loblaw joins sustainable beef marketplace January 12, 2021
          View all Livestock
        • Livestock Sales
  • Markets
          • Only a trio of cattle auctions to start 2021 January 15, 2021
          • Canola values’ climb likely to continue January 14, 2021
          • Taiwan lawmakers approve imports of additive-fed U.S. pork January 12, 2021
          View all Markets
        • Markets at a glance
  • Weather
      • Livestock sector benefiting from mild winter weather January 15, 2021
      • Forecast: Colder, but not much snow expected January 14, 2021
      • No getting off the carbon reduction train January 12, 2021
      • Top weather stories of 2020 January 7, 2021
      View all Weather
  • Farmit
      • People, relationships the highlight of a long career January 13, 2021
      • Foray into ag opened opportunities unknown January 11, 2021
      • Stories of hard Christmases past December 25, 2020
      • Home ice advantage: Backyard rinks a winter oasis December 24, 2020
      View all Farmit
  • Op/Ed
      • Comment: Farmers should get on board with green future January 13, 2021
      • Comment: The top 10 food stories of 2020 January 11, 2021
      • Comment: Stepping up to help Prairie farmers January 6, 2021
      • Comment: Households are getting sandwiched January 4, 2021
      View all Op/Ed
  • Digital Editions
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Classified
  • Place Ad
Manitoba Co-operator
Free Newsletter Signup

Your Reading List

  • Canola Pool, Maybe. Wheat? Probably Not

    August 11, 2011 Cereals
  • Canola Tops For Farm Cash Receipts In 2010

    August 4, 2011 Cereals
  • Strong Dollar Tempers Canola Export Demand

    July 28, 2011 Cereals
  • Fruit Crops Look Good — Except Those Under Water

    July 21, 2011 Crops
  • UN Expert Urges Huge Investment In Small Farmers

    July 14, 2011 Crops
Manitoba Co-operator
MENUMENU
  • News
      • Livestock sector benefiting from mild winter weather January 15, 2021
      • Innovations Showcase heads up reined-in Ag Days January 14, 2021
      • Swath of MARD, MASC offices slated for closure January 14, 2021
      • Biologicals in agriculture: what’s old is new (and improved) January 13, 2021
      View all News
  • Crops
      • Biologicals in agriculture: what’s old is new (and improved) January 13, 2021
      • Canola ending stocks forecast lowered January 7, 2021
      • Targeting your crop enemies January 5, 2021
      • Overwintered canola can still have value, but process it quickly December 30, 2020
      View all Crops
  • Livestock
          • Livestock sector benefiting from mild winter weather January 15, 2021
          • Providing “a good death” for your horse when the time comes January 13, 2021
          • Loblaw joins sustainable beef marketplace January 12, 2021
          View all Livestock
        • Livestock Sales
  • Markets
          • Only a trio of cattle auctions to start 2021 January 15, 2021
          • Canola values’ climb likely to continue January 14, 2021
          • Taiwan lawmakers approve imports of additive-fed U.S. pork January 12, 2021
          View all Markets
        • Markets at a glance
  • Weather
      • Livestock sector benefiting from mild winter weather January 15, 2021
      • Forecast: Colder, but not much snow expected January 14, 2021
      • No getting off the carbon reduction train January 12, 2021
      • Top weather stories of 2020 January 7, 2021
      View all Weather
  • Farmit
      • People, relationships the highlight of a long career January 13, 2021
      • Foray into ag opened opportunities unknown January 11, 2021
      • Stories of hard Christmases past December 25, 2020
      • Home ice advantage: Backyard rinks a winter oasis December 24, 2020
      View all Farmit
  • Op/Ed
      • Comment: Farmers should get on board with green future January 13, 2021
      • Comment: The top 10 food stories of 2020 January 11, 2021
      • Comment: Stepping up to help Prairie farmers January 6, 2021
      • Comment: Households are getting sandwiched January 4, 2021
      View all Op/Ed
  • Digital Editions
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Classified
  • Place Ad

Facebook Twitter Instagram

BIG SAVINGS | WITH GLACIER FARMMEDIA MEMBERSHIP | LEARN MORE

manitoba co-operator | response to covid-19

Special coverage | COVID-19 & the Farm

BIG SAVINGS | WITH GLACIER FARMMEDIA MEMBERSHIP | LEARN MORE

manitoba co-operator | response to covid-19

Special coverage | COVID-19 & the Farm

Canola Pool, Maybe. Wheat? Probably Not

John Morriss
By John Morriss
Reading Time: 3 minutes
Published: August 11, 2011
Cereals, Oilseeds, Opinion

As we pointed out last week, opponents of the CWB monopoly are doing their best to distance themselves from the reality that ending the monopoly means ending the board altogether. They are throwing out red herrings claiming that the CWB would still be around in some fashion, including one that the board could run a pool for the farmers who wanted it.

This battle is over and farmers may or may not be better off for it, but let’s go into this with both eyes wide open. A voluntary pool may sound like a good idea, but it’s a non-starter.

ADVERTISEMENT

First, this has nothing to do with the board surviving as a sales agency. Assuming the pool could work, you wouldn’t necessarily need a wheat board to run it. All you’d need is a few people with computers, a spreadsheet program and a bank account. When you sold to a grain company, wheat board or otherwise, it would send the money to the pool, which would issue the initial payment, calculate the returns at the end of the crop year, and issue a final payment.

You could even run a pool for canola. In fact, that might work fairly well. There’s only one main grade, and canola is sold pretty much evenly through the crop year. Calculating representative returns would be reasonably straightforward.

Wheat is another matter. There are dozens of classes, grades and protein levels. This is where it gets tricky.

ADVERTISEMENT

Let’s assume that it’s been a good harvest year across the Prairies, with most wheat grading 1 CW or 2 CW, but you were one of the unlucky ones with a couple of showers at harvest and you pulled off a crop of 3 CW. However, the wheat board finds a market for a couple of cargoes in October and takes it all off your hands, selling it to a customer for $200 per tonne. No. 1 CW selling on the same day is fetching $250.

Soon after, there are concerns about crop conditions in other countries and wheat prices rise sharply. For the entire crop year, No. 1 CW ends up selling for an average of $350.

Should you only get $200 for your 3 CW, $150 per tonne or $4 per bushel less than your luckier neighbour with 1 CW?

What if the market went in the other direction, with your 3 CW getting $300 when it was sold but 1 CW averaging only $250 for the year? Should you get more for your lower-quality wheat?

You would probably answer “no” to the first question and your neighbour with 1 CW would definitely answer “no” to the second.

ADVERTISEMENT

POOLING IS NOT AVERAGING

However, because of the way the wheat board runs the pooling system, such situations almost never arise. That’s because while pooling is often referred to as “price averaging,” it’s not. In determining payments for each class or grade; the CWB doesn’t calculate the average selling price. It calculates the average “spread,” or difference between them, for the entire crop year. Otherwise, in order to be fair, it would have to sell one-twelfth of each class and grade every month of the crop year, which would be logistically impossible.

Right now the system works because the board sells everything, and knows what numbers to put into the formula. If it’s only selling dribs and drabs of different grades at different times through the year, the process becomes arbitrary.

And what if it doesn’t get much grain into the pool, which you can bet it wouldn’t in a rising market? Where does the money come from to distribute a fair price to that 3 CW grower, even if it could be calculated? Certainly not from a government guarantee, which would be unfair to other companies.

Even if the pool could be actuarily sound, it would need a large number of growers to commit in advance (subject to legal action) to ensure that deliveries didn’t dry up in a rising market.

There’s not much evidence that they would. Perhaps the largest corporate failure in Canadian history was the Prairie Pools’ voluntary wheat-marketing agency in 1929. And last winter, the Manitoba Canola Growers Association floated the idea of a voluntary canola pool (again, which might actually work) and received little support. In fact, it received considerable abuse, notably from some of the same critics who are now dumping on the wheat board for lack of gumption or imagination in offering a voluntary wheat pool.

So let’s go through this again. This battle is over. The Conservative government is going to remove the CWB monopoly. Farmers may or may not be better off, but the sun will still rise and set and wheat and barley will still be grown and sold.

However, it will not be sold by the Canadian Wheat Board. If the government has any shred of decency it will retire the name rather than maintaining it on some toothless version of its former self, especially on some pooling scheme that’s bound to fail. Pooling, like the board itself, is going to disappear into history. [email protected]

About the author

John Morriss's recent articles

  • The year captured in verse — without one single curse December 31, 2020
  • (Former) Editor’s Take: Our most important customer August 6, 2020
  • Opinion: ‘Canadian grain — it won’t hurt you’ June 12, 2020

More Articles

Related Coverage

Oilseeds, Canola


Canola ending stocks forecast lowered

Oilseeds, Canola


Overwintered canola can still have value, but process it quickly

Cereals, Barley


Canadian Malting Barley Technical Centre issues 2021-22 recommended malting barley varieties list

Cereals, Wheat


Greig to chair wheat research council

Oilseeds, Canola


With canola prices on the rise, time to make a marketing plan

Opinion, Wheat


Comment: ‘How much evidence do you need to vaporize a zombie?’

Comments

explore

Stories from our other publications

  • The Western Producer

    Farmers propose tying carbon credits to carbon tax

    crops

    Farmers propose tying carbon credits to carbon tax

  • The Western Producer

    Number of fields infected with clubroot increases in Sask.

    crops

    Number of fields infected with clubroot increases in Sask.

  • The Western Producer

    Alta. municipality anticipates pulse potential

    crops

    Alta. municipality anticipates pulse potential

  • The Western Producer

    Pull the big planter with the big 4-wheel drive tractor

    crops

    Pull the big planter with the big 4-wheel drive tractor

GFM Network News

  • Alberta’s Lakeland to offer ag tech degree

    1 day ago
  • Funds’ net long position edges lower in canola

    1 day ago
  • Prairie cash wheat: Bids track rally in U.S. futures

    1 day ago
More News →

Podcasts

  • between-the-rows
  • Rural internet inadequacies, underground enemies, rodeo rider interrupted, canola markets ignite

    January 14, 2021
  • Listen Now →

Special Podcast

Between The Rows

  • Listen » Reflections on pandemic life. How are we doing?

AgCanadaTV

AGCanadaTV: In Case You Missed It – Your National Ag News Recap for the week ending January 15, 2021.

Sponsored By:
More Videos →

Daily Newsletter

Subscribe to the Manitoba Co-operator daily newsletter

You'll receive current daily news every morning free, as well as market updates and special features.

* PERMISSION TO CONTACT YOU BY EMAIL By providing your e-mail address, you confirm that you are providing consent to Glacier Farm Media LP, on its own behalf and on behalf of its affiliates, and carrying on business through its divisions, to receive emails containing news, updates and promotions, including third party promotions, as well as product and/or service information, including that of third parties, that may be of interest to you, and that you understand you may unsubscribe at any time. Please see contact us for more information.


flag
Signup to our Newsletter
  • News & Opinion
  • Crops
  • Livestock
  • Markets
  • Farmit
  • Video
  • Digital Editions
  • Classifieds
  • Subscriptions
  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise

Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy | © 2021, Glacier FarmMedia Limited Partnership

Banner image Close

With roots going back to 1925, each weekly issue of the Manitoba Co-operator contains production, marketing and policy news selected for relevance to crops and livestock producers in Manitoba.

Subscribe Today!

Free Newsletter Signup