Farm fuel exemption hung up in Senate

If an election is called the private member’s bill will be effectively dead

Carbon tax relief for grain dryer fuels is slowly inching its way through Ottawa.

A widely supported law intending to exempt grain-drying costs from federal carbon pricing might not get passed, despite gaining enough support from MPs.

Canada’s Senate adjourned on June 29, and isn’t scheduled to return until Sept. 21.

If an election is called in the interim, as many expect, legislation not passed by the Senate effectively dies.

Conservative Party MP Philip Lawrence saw this iteration of his Bill C-206 start working its way through the House of Commons in September, 2020.

Aimed at offering financial relief from carbon pricing for farmers drying grain, the bill is widely supported by industry groups and MPs outside of the governing Liberals.

Minister of Agriculture Marie-Claude Bibeau had been lobbied since 2019 to offer a broader exemption from carbon costs than what was already being offered to producers.

An evaluation of grain-drying costs provided by some provincial governments and producer groups was done in 2019 by Agriculture Canada. That report found the average annual per-farm cost of pollution pricing from grain drying cost between $210 and $774.

In instances where a province has an adequate carbon pricing plan of its own, the federal policy doesn’t apply – the analysis was done using information from provinces subject to the federal government at that time.

Bibeau had previously said carbon costs for grain drying were not having a “significant impact” on farmers’ bottom lines.

But in March, hours prior to a significant vote on Lawrence’s exemption, Bibeau and Liberal colleagues announced their minority government was committed to “new rebates.”

They argued Bill C-206 wouldn’t adequately offer the exemptions it intended to offer, but promised a Liberal-created exemption that would.

Budget 2021 committed the federal government to returning a greater portion of the taxes paid on natural gas and propane. It also introduced a program to assist producers to buy fuel-efficient grain dryers.

While the Conservative and Liberal solutions are different, they both aim to address the cost of carbon costs burdening farmers.

About the author


D.C. Fraser

D.C. Fraser is Glacier FarmMedia’s Ottawa-based reporter. Growing up mostly in Alberta, Fraser also lived in Saskatchewan for ten years where he covered politics, including a stint teaching at the University of Regina’s School of Journalism. He is an avid fan of the outdoors and a pretty good beer league hockey player. His passion for agriculture and agri-food policy comes naturally: Six consecutive generations of his family have worked in the industry.



Stories from our other publications