Philadelphia | Reuters — Republican Senator Ted Cruz of Texas on Wednesday urged President Donald Trump’s administration to push for an overhaul of the nation’s biofuels policy, during a rally at a Pennsylvania oil refinery that blames its bankruptcy on the controversial regulation.
“We need a federal government that stands up for workers, not against them,” Cruz, whose state is home to numerous oil refining companies, told a cheering crowd of 1,200 people gathered in a tent on the grounds of the Philadelphia Energy Solutions (PES) plant.
The oil industry and the corn lobby have been at odds over the causes of the Philadelphia-area refiner’s insolvency, which has become a touchstone in the debate over whether the U.S. Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) needs to be rewritten.
The decade-old regulation requires U.S. refiners to blend biofuels like corn-based ethanol into their fuel, or buy credits from those who do. While it has created a lucrative market for corn states like Iowa and Nebraska, refiners such as PES that have no blending facilities say it is unfair and costly.
PES, which employs more than 1,000 people, declared bankruptcy in January and placed the blame squarely at the feet of the RFS.
The corn industry has pushed back, pointing out that other refining companies — such as top U.S. refiner Valero Energy — are raking in their biggest profits in years, and suggesting PES’ problems may have had more to do with regional refining economics and management choices.
Reuters reported this week that PES’ investor backers — led by the Carlyle Group — withdrew at least US$594 million in a series of dividend-style distributions from PES since 2012, most of them backed by loans the company ultimately could not repay. The distributions, combined with a shift in U.S. energy economics, made complying with the RFS a challenge.
“Workers at PES deserve real answers for the financial troubles facing the refinery, and that starts with investors who drained the company while other U.S. refiners flourished under the RFS,” said Emily Skor, chief executive of biofuels producer Growth Energy.
Cruz has been leading an effort to reform the RFS, putting holds on presidential nominations favoured by corn-state lawmakers and organizing meetings with administration officials.
The oil and gas industry is among Cruz’s top financial backers, according to the Center for Responsive Politics. Cruz has suggested putting a cap of 10 cents on credit prices — a fraction of their current value — in a move that would save refiners millions of dollars but which was roundly rejected as unworkable by the biofuels industry.
Cruz said on Wednesday that, despite his free market principles, he supports capping prices of the credits, called RINs: “A RIN is not a commodity… it’s a made-up government license,” he said.
The former presidential hopeful said that his proposal would help refiners without hurting corn growers. He added that if he had won the 2016 race for the White House, he would have done more than suggest tweaks to the program.
“If I would’ve won, I would’ve ended the RFS,” Cruz said to a round of applause.
PES is asking a bankruptcy judge to shed roughly US$350 million of its current RFS compliance costs as part of its restructuring package. Complying with the RFS was more expensive than the company’s payroll, and ranked only behind purchasing crude oil as its biggest cost, according to PES.
— Jarrett Renshaw reports on the U.S. energy sector for Reuters from New York.