To till or not to till? For soybeans that’s the question

The Westman Agricultural Diversification Organization is testing out planting dates and 
pre-seed tillage systems in its latest round of soybean experiments

Dr. Yvonne Lawley of the University of Manitoba presents initial data in front of her newest line of plots evaluating the impact of tillage on soybeans.

Conventional wisdom says to break out the harrow before planting soybeans, the better to expose black earth and warm the soil, but new research is putting that assumption to the test.

Dr. Yvonne Lawley of the Unive­rsity of Manitoba is measuring the effect of seeding date and different tillage systems on soybeans through several regions of the province.

“We see soybeans moving into areas where we have predominantly no till,” Lawley said at the recent field day at the Westman Agricultural Diversification Organ­ization (WADO) site near Melita, where some of her plots are located this year.

“My concern is that we’re forgoing soil management to make this new crop work.”

Growing crop

Once a rare sight in the province, soybeans have become one of the most popular crops in terms of acres seeded this year, driving the need for more research.

This summer is the second and final year of Lawley’s project. The experiment tests both an early and late seeding date under three systems: no till, strip till and conventional disc tillage.

In 2016, test sites in Carman showed little difference in yield between tillage systems at either early or late seeding dates, while disc tillage pulled ahead in Melita’s early-seeded plots. Yields in Melita’s conventionally tilled plots easily topped 30 bushels per acre, followed closely by strip tillage while no till trailed at just over 25 bushels per acre.

Later-seeded plots, however, per­formed well in southwest Mani­toba when planted into standing stubble, yielding the highest of the three tillage systems.

“I think what surprises me the most is probably the difference between the tillage treatments in 2016 versus 2017 where we have very different environmental conditions,” Lawley said.

Wet conditions in 2016 have been replaced this spring and summer by dry weather. While not as dry as central Saskatchewan, most of Manitoba’s agricultural landscape has received just 60 to 85 per cent of average precipitation.

“In 2016, we saw that our conventional-till treatment had good stand establishment — like our strip-till treatment — compared to the no till, but then this year we had really dry conditions during soybean emergence. We saw the complete opposite, where we had good conditions in no till, and probably the best conditions in our strip-till treatment again — that’s at least consistent between the two years.”

Moisture for emergence

Conventional tillage, however, struggled in 2017 as the same disturbance that exposed black soil also dried out already thirsty plots.

Disc-tilled plots showed by far the lowest plant establishment of the three early-seeded tillage systems, hovering around 2,000 plants per acre, compared to well over 6,000 plants per acre in zero-tilled soils and well over 8,000 plants per acre in strip-tilled plots.

In contrast, late-planted plots hovered roughly between 4,000 and 5,000 plants per acre in all three systems, with disc tillage having the highest plant density and no till, the lowest.

“Later plantings, it didn’t really matter. It was all about soil moisture for emergence,” Scott Chalmers, crop diversification specialist with Manitoba Agriculture and WADO manager, said. “Conventional tillage was the wrong practice to do in this situation this year. It just dried everything out and that also happened to us in the corn plots this year. We just couldn’t find moisture because we tilled to get the fertilizer in.”

Manitoba Agriculture diversification specialist Scott Chalmers addresses the crowd during the Westman Agricultural Diversification Organization tour July 25. photo: Alexis Stockford

Lawley’s research also showed that strip-tillage soil warmth topped out both other treatments in the first 14 days after planting this year. Lawley counted accumulated degrees over 10 C at planting depth and noted daily peak temperatures in particular were warmer under strip tillage.

“When you’re using strip till, there’s a round, kind of concave surface, and that rounded surface catches more solar radiation than a flat surface, which is typically left in the conventional till,” she said. “In one experiment where we were working with corn residue and we had a really rough surface and essentially had peaks and valleys, there we saw similar trends.”

The effect may be temporary, since press wheels after seeding flatten the berm, she added.

How early is early?

Across the field from Lawley’s WADO tillage trials, soybean and pulse research agronomist Kristen MacMillan, also of the University of Manitoba, is testing four planting dates starting in late April and progressing roughly every 10 days.

“The traditional recommendation is waiting until it’s 10 C and the risk of frost has passed. Farmers have already tested that recommendation and they’ve had success in some areas, so before farmers in every region of Manitoba who are growing soybeans go out and plant the last week of April or the first week of May, we want to test it, because it can be risky,” she said.

Kristen MacMillan gives field day attendees a sneak peek into the first year of her research on soybean seeding dates July 25 near Melita. photo: Alexis Stockford

MacMillan planted both an early- and late-maturing variety at each date and the experiment has been replicated in a number of regions, including Arborg to the north and Carman and Morden in south-central Manitoba.

“This is just the first year of the trial, so I don’t have any yield data, but we’ve looked at growth staging and flowering,” MacMillan said.

Plants at both Arborg and Carman began flowering in the same short window, regardless of seeding date, initial results showed.

“They’re short-day plants,” MacMillan said “As soon as that summer solstice hits on June 21, they’ll generally start to flower within a week or two after that, so the flowering window across the seeding windows has been only about 10-12 days, which is not necessarily surprising, but it’s just kind of interesting that we have a 35-day seeding window, but they’re all flowering within 10-12 days of one another.”

Biomass and canopy closure is also being measured at flowering, part of MacMillan’s quest to determine if growth staging at anthesis can predict final yield performance.

About the author


Alexis Stockford

Alexis Stockford is a journalist and photographer with the Manitoba Co-operator. She previously reported with the Morden Times and was news editor of  campus newspaper, The Omega, at Thompson Rivers University in Kamloops, BC. She grew up on a mixed farm near Miami, Man.



Stories from our other publications