Your Reading List

Reglone Versus Glyphosate

They’ve (Reglone and glyphosate) been

around for many years. They work totally differently, but as I say confusion still reigns.”

– ED THIESSEN

Reglone (diquat) and glyphosate are similar, but different and farmers need to know the difference to get the best results from each, says Ed Thiessen of Syngenta Canada.

Both are non-selective herbicides that when applied pre-harvest can speed up combining. But Reglone is a true crop desiccant, while glyphosate is for perennial weed control, Thiessen told the Manitoba Agronomists Conference at the University of Manitoba Dec. 15.

“Farmers view glyphosate as a desiccant,” Thiessen said. “We don’t view it as a desiccant at all. They’ve (Reglone and glyphosate) been around for many years. They work totally differently, but as I say confusion still reigns.”

DIFFERENT MODES OF ACTION

Glyphosate is a systemic, moving through plants into their roots. It provides good perennial weed control, but also needs time to work.

Reglone is a contact herbicide that burns off plant leaves very quickly.

Both help crops and weeds dry down allowing combines to start harvesting sooner, but neither product speeds up seed maturity as many farmers incorrectly believe.

“If you apply either of these two products to a crop too early that is immature you can get inconsistency in desiccation, you can certainly lose yield, you can lose quality,” Thiessen said. “Pulse crops are particularly susceptible if you go too early.”

In fact, for Reglone to work best, the crop should be senescing (hitting the final stages of maturing), he said. If they’re not, sometime plants regrow after being sprayed, especially indeterminate maturing crops.

In contrast, glyphosate works best when the plant is still actively growing.

UNREALISTIC EXPECTATIONS

Both herbicides were widely used this fall “and saved the day” for many farmers, Thiessen said. But some farmers – mostly desiccant novices – were disappointed partly because they had unrealistic expectations.

Proper application is key to getting the best performance from each product, Thiessen said. Farmers need to know what the target is – the crop or the weeds – and adjust their spray boom height accordingly.

Good coverage is critical, especially for a contact herbicide like Reglone. The more water that’s applied the better. Slower sprayer travelling speeds will also result in better coverage.

Water quality is important too. Hard water reduces glyphosate’s effectiveness and Reglone won’t work as well when mixed with dirty water. Reglone also needs an adjuvant.

Both herbicides work better on some crops than others, Thiessen said. Glyphosate is more effective on grassy plants, while Reglone works best on broadleaf plants.

“Reglone is used on peas, lentils, potatoes – things like that,” he said. “That’s where its strength is.”

Glyphosate is good at “evening up” cereals, while Reglone isn’t registered in cereals and shouldn’t be used, Thiessen said.

NOT FOR MALTING BARLEY

Glyphosate is not registered for use in malting barley either. The herbicide can leave a residue that could turn up in beer. Moreover, glyphosate reduces seed germination, which interferes with the malting process. That’s also why it shouldn’t be used on seed crops.

Reglone doesn’t affect seed germination.

A lot of farmers wanted to use Reglone on canola this year, but Thiessen recommended against it, saying it would result in pods shattering and severe yield losses.

Reglone works well on sunflowers, he said.

“Glyphosate will work, but it is very slow and a lot of guys ran into head rot issues (partly because of the delay in harvesting),” Thiessen said.

USING BOTH AN OPTION

Farmers don’t have to pick between pre-harvest weed control and desiccation, Thiessen said. They can do both, but not at the same time, Thiessen said. Applying both Reglone and glyphosate at the same time doesn’t work because the Reglone burns off plant leaves before transferring the glyphosate throughout the plant. Applying them separately costs $35 to $50 an acre.

“There are people who do this each year and certainly the performance is phenomenal, but it’s a question if they need that and if they can afford it,” Thiessen said.

In such cases the glyphosate should be applied first. [email protected]

About the author

Reporter

Allan Dawson

Allan Dawson is a reporter with the Manitoba Co-operator based near Miami, Man. Covering agriculture since 1980, Dawson has spent most of his career with the Co-operator except for several years with Farmers’ Independent Weekly and before that a Morden-Winkler area radio station.

Comments

explore

Stories from our other publications